Category Archives: Little Red Dual Citizenshipi Book

Canadian Citizenship By Descent – A Search For Proof (To Prove The Truth) – 4 Perspectives

John Richardson, J.D. – August 13, 2026

Introduction

This is the second post in a series of posts designed to explore Canadian citizenship generally and Canada’s citizenship by descent rules specifically. The first post (which I suggest you read first) explained how Canada’s citizenship by descent rules work. If you haven’t read it, I suggest that you read it now.

Understanding The Citizenship By Descent Provisions Of Bill C-3 – The Canada Citizenship Act

For those who prefer a visual blueprint to determine whether you ARE a Canadian citizen see:

Bill_C3_Citizenship_Blueprint

This post is organized in the following parts:

Part A – The difference between knowing what to do and doing what you know!

Part B – Proving your parent was a Canadian citizen

Part C – Proving 1095 days of physical presence

Let’s begin.

Continue reading

Understanding The Citizenship By Descent Provisions Of Bill C-3 – The Canada Citizenship Act

By John Richardson, J.D. – Toronto, Canada – August 9, 2026

I have organized this post into the following Parts:

Introduction – Explaining the purpose

Part A – Canada’s citizenship by descent law from December 15, 2025 – What the law says

Part B – Understanding the language of Bill C-3 Canada’s citizenship by descent rules

Part C – Parsing the language of Bill C-3: How the legislation compels these conclusions

Part D – A Review: What is the legislative source of these conclusions? How does one get there? – The Text of relevant parts of Bill C-3

Part E – In Summary

Appendix A – Canada Citizenship Act

Appendix B – Canada Justice Minister – Explanation of Bill C-3

Appendix C – Bill C-3 Backgrounder

Appendix D – How To Apply For A Certificate Of Canadian Citizenship

Appendix E – Legislative Summary Of Bill C-3

Appendix F – The Complete Text Of Section 3 Of the Canada Citzenship Act

Introduction – Explaining the purpose

The purpose of this post is narrow. It is to explain how the new “citizenship by descent rules” follow from the text of Section 3(1) of The Canada Citizenship Act.

https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/C-29/page-1.html#docCont

Bill C-3 – Canada’s new citizenship law – Effective December 15, 2025

I am going to be honest. I find it very difficult to read the Canada Citizenship Act and make sense of it. I understand what the commentators say that it says. That’s great. But I feel more comfortable if I can understand the legislation, parse the legislation and understand how the sections fit together.

Bottom line: If somebody asks you:

Q. Where in the Canada Citizenship Act does it specifically say that, if a child is born outside of Canada, after December 14, 2025, to a parent who was a Canadian citizen and that Canadian citizen parent was also born outside of Canada, then that parent is required to have 1095 days of physical presence in Canada prior to the child’s birth in order to transmit citizenship to the child?

A. Well, you better be able to provide an answer.

Continue reading

Thoughts On Ohio Senator Moreneo’s “Exclusive Citizenship Act Of 2025”

Background

On December 1, 2025 Ohio Senator Bernie Moreno, tabled his “Exclusive Citizenship Act Of 2025″.

A pdf of the proposed legislation is available here:

Exclusive-Citizenship-Act-of-2025

The progress of the legislation (if any) may be followed here.

It was immediately understood that the Moreno bill would affect both Melania and Baron Trump, each of whom has dual U.S./Slovenian citizenship.


My comments on the proposed legislation fall into ten categories:

1. What the Bill is intended to achieve

2. What the Bill assumes about the meaning of citizenship

3. Constitutionality – Conflicts with the 14th Amendment

4. Inside Looking Out (American dual citizens living inside the United States)

5. Outside looking in (Americans Dual Citizens Abroad)

6. Effect on Green Card Holders – Will they naturalize as U.S. citizens?

7. Creating a data base of citizenship and multiple citizenships

8. Creating a situation where the laws of another country could impact who can enter politics and serve in public office in the United States

9. Effect on Internal Revenue Code 877A – Will an Exit Tax be payable if a U.S. citizen is deemed to have relinquished U.S. citizenship?

10. The Secretary Of State and the authority to make regulations

Possible conclusion:

Should the Moreno bill be enacted it would fundamentally change the nature of U.S. citizenship which already carries significant restrictions and obligations. It would certainly associate U.S. citizenship with a general loss of freedom.

It is blatantly obvious that in the 21st century that U.S. citizenship is NOT compatible with the freedom of the individual.

Continue reading

Part 6 – What Would A Ban On Dual Citizenship Mean For U.S. Citizens?

The Little Red Dual Citizenship Book

See the Appendix for a list of posts making up the “Little Red Dual Citizenship Book”

Whether or not it’s “fake news” …

It started with what purported to be a post by President Trump on “Truth Social” that he was going to attempt to end dual citizenship. This was immediately exposed as a “Fake Post”. Nevertheless, I came across an interesting video of what it would mean if Americans were somehow banned from being dual citizens. Without regard to the “fakeness” of the claim that President Trump was interested in ending dual citizenship, the video is interesting.

John Richardson – Follow me on X.com @ExpatriationLaw

Appendix – Posts That Make Up The “Little Red Dual Citizenship Book”

Part 1 – Dual Citizenship Reporting

Part 1 – Citizenship-based reporting: Russia’s "citizenship reporting" requirements – will the United States be next?

Part 2 – Under What Circumstances Is Citizenship By Ancestry Justified?

Part 2 – Citizenship Matters With @RonanMcCrea: Citizenship By Descent Can Be High Risk For A Country In A Less Global World

Part 3 – Could U.S./Canada Dual Citizens Residing In Canada Determine The Outcome Of A U.S. Election? (The Democrats Hope So)

Part 3 – Could The November 3, 2020 US Election Be Decided By Canadian Residents With US/CDN Dual Citizenship?


Part 4 – A Change In Canadian Law Increase Canadian “Citizenship Through Ancestry” Options For Americans

Part 4 – Canada Bill – C71 Will Increase Citizenship By Descent Options For US Citizens Seeking Canada/US Dual Citizenship

Part 5 – When Dual Citizenship For The Individual, Becomes “Duel Citizenship” For The State

Part 5 – The Clash Of Citizenships: When Dual Citizenship For The Individual Becomes Duel Citizenship For The State

Part 6 – What Would Ending Dual Citizenship Look Like For U.S. Citizens?

Part 6 – What Would A Ban On Dual Citizenship Mean For U.S. Citizens?

Part 4 – Canada Bill – C71 Will Increase Citizenship By Descent Options For US Citizens Seeking Canada/US Dual Citizenship

Introduction And Summary

This is Part 4 in my “Little Red Dual Citizenship Book” Series. For parts 1 to 5, see the Appendix.

A recent article in the Boston Globe is evidence that more and more Americans are interested in acquiring a second citizenship. Second citizenship can be obtained through naturalization, investment or citizenship by descent. “Citizenship by descent” is citizenship conferred based on one’s relationship – ancestry – to a parent or grandparent. The nature of the ancestral relationship depends on the country. Countries offering citizenship by descent include: Italy, Ireland, Poland, Canada and many other European countries. Citizenship by ancestry is often referred to as “citizenship by descent”. The basic principle is that one acquires citizenship because of a familial relationship to a citizen of that country. Increasing numbers of people are learning that through ancestry, they may be able acquire or document a second citizenship.

An option for “citizenship by descent” that is much closer to home – Canada – will soon be an option for more U.S. citizens than it is under exiting law.

Citizenship By Descent – Equal Treatment And Opportunity For All Canadian Citizens

The precise rules governing citizenship by descent vary from country to country. The rules governing citizenship by descent have many difficulties. Should ANY citizen be able to pass his/her citizenship on to the next generation? Does the physical connection to the country of citizenship matter? Should citizenship by descent rules operate so that acquisition of descent can be available for many generations? These questions were explored in the context of Canada’s Charter of Rights And Freedoms.

Continue reading

Part 3 – Could The November 3, 2020 US Election Be Decided By Canadian Residents With US/CDN Dual Citizenship?

Introduction

This is Part 3 in my “Little Red Dual Citizenship Book” Series. For parts 1 to 5, see the Appendix.

A recent opinion piece published at CBC included:

I have been walking around these days asking myself with only half a smile whether there is some morphed version of the Canadian national anthem which declares: “True expatriate love in all thy sons and daughters command.”

I am doing this because I have been regularly experiencing what you might call expatriate shaming.

There’s been a push — no, make that a shove — to recruit Americans living in Canada who are eligible to vote in the Nov. 3 presidential election to become part of the electoral process. Knowing I was born in the U.S., my friends, neighbours and relatives will ask with a semi-desperate twinge in their voices: “Have you registered to vote in the U.S. election?” And when I say I am registered but I do not plan to vote, they get very angry.

Given what has been going on under President Donald Trump, they exclaim, how can I even think about not making a difference by casting a presidential ballot? (By the way, no one assumes that an expat could possibly vote for Trump, which is interesting.)

https://www.cbc.ca/news/opinion/opinion-expats-canada-presidential-election-vote-1.5750417

The VoteFromAbroad.org Push To Get “US Citizens” (Whoever They May Be) Living In Canada To Vote

Continue reading

Part 2 – Citizenship Matters With @RonanMcCrea: Citizenship By Descent Can Be High Risk For A Country In A Less Global World

Prologue – Citizens Abroad, The Right To Return And A Possible Right To Vote

This is Part 2 in my “Little Red Dual Citizenship Book” Series. For parts 1 to 5, see the Appendix.

In 1987, This Toronto Star article referenced in the above tweet may be read in its entirety as follows:

Page 1

out

Page 2

H5

The Toronto Star identifies some of the problems associated with citizenship policies that are overly generous. Interestingly (see the Appendix) in 2009 Canada attempted to address these problems through amendments to the Citizenship Act.

The 1987 Toronto Star article is very similar to a 2020 article written by Professor Ronan McCrae where he argues that (among other things) that citizens abroad should not have the right to vote.

Continue reading

Part 1 – Citizenship-based reporting: Russia’s "citizenship reporting" requirements – will the United States be next?

Prologue – A law firm perspective …

This is Part 1 of my “Little Red Dual Citizenship Book” series. For Parts 1 to 5, See the Appendix To This Post.

As reported by Chelco Vat:

The law does not make dual citizenship illegal; it is merely a reporting requirement.
Federal Law No. 142-FZ on Amendment of Articles 6 and 30 of the Federal Law on Russian Federation Citizenship and Individual Regulations of the Russian Federation, which took effect on 4 August 2014, makes it a criminal offence for Russian nationals to conceal dual citizenship or long-term residence abroad.

Hmmmm … ONLY a reporting requirement you say …

The perspective of an individual subject to the citizenship-reporting requirement …

The above tweet references an article in the New York Times discussing Russia’s law that requires all Russians with a second foreign citizenship report that foreign citizenship to the Government.

Continue reading